20 Best Free Music Apps for iPhone and Android

If there is one thing that seems to travel with us almost everywhere – from relaxation at home to long drives to late-night parties, it is music. Whether we are overjoyed, calm, or saddened by a sudden heartbreak, most of us like to listen to music to keep. In this digital age, music has become more accessible than ever before with many notable brands launching top-notch music apps for on-demand streaming. But just in case you are finding it a bit hard to discover which one can live up to your billing, we have got you covered with the 20 best free music apps for Android and iPhone in 2021.

Top Free Music Apps for Android and iOS in 2021

Remember, no music app is perfect. At the end of the day, everything boils down to what your needs demand or what suits your taste better. What may seem to be an effortless pick for me may not sound appealing to you.

That’s why I have handpicked a variety of music apps that can elegantly cater to your on-demand music and radio listening. Oh yes, I have also included some offline music apps for iOS and Android so that you can enjoy your own music collection.

1. Spotify

When there is a discussion for the overall best music apps across the platforms, the one obvious name that strikes the mind instantly is Spotify. And rightly so as it’s by far the most feature-rich and elegant music app for both iOS and Android.

What has always impressed me the most in Spotify is the very intuitive user interface.  And even so, there are lot of Spotify tips and tricks that can make your experience that much better. And with the colossal music library of more than 50 million songs, it’s ever ready to offer any song that you want to hear. The app pays special attention to your interest and offers recommendations accordingly. In fact, in my experience, Spotify has the best music recommendation feature of all the music streaming services.

Spotify

You can also craft your personal playlists of all of your favorite songs and even share them with your friends and vice-versa. With Spotify Premium ($9.99/monthly), you can unlock several impressive features. For instance, you will be allowed to listen to your songs offline, use the app without any ads, and also get better sound quality.

Moreover, Spotify also comes with tons of podcasts and is one of the best podcasts app out there as well. So, if you are a loyal podcast listener, you’d be glad to have its massive library at your disposal. What’s more, you can even create radio stations on Spotify. Finally, it’s available in more than 90 countries, so most of us can access and use it. Everything considered; it’s one of the best free music apps for iPhone and Android.

Pros: 

  • A massive library of music
  • Intuitive user-interface 
  • Personalized recommendations 
  • Offers thousands of podcasts 

Cons: 

  • The sound quality of freemium version is comparatively poor 

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod (can’t be set as default)

Install: iOS and Android (free, $9.99/month)

2. YouTube Music

YouTube Music is a top-notch music app from Google. If you like to keep a track of the official release or singles from your favorite artists, it will keep you at pace with your interest. Plus, it’s known to deliver the most suitable recommendations as per several things including your taste, location, and even mood.

Another department where YouTube Music has made plenty of strides is refining the entire UI which makes it a lot easier to browse through albums, live performances, remixes, personalized playlists, and more. Besides, the advanced search plays a vital role in quickly finding a song or album. But what has caught my eyes in this app is the hotlist which offers quick access to all the songs that are trending.

YouTube Music

One advantage of YouTube Music is that it also lets you access official videos, live performances, and more, right from the app. This means you have access to different versions of songs which is not quite possible on other free music streaming platforms.

And if you are willing to spend some bucks, you can go for YouTube Premium ($9.99) to listen to music ad-free, get a download option, and more. Talking about availability, the paid version of YouTube Music is available in more than 65 countries which include countries like the USA, Canada, UK, India, Sweden, Australia, and, more.

Pros: 

  • An ever-growing library of songs 
  • Features a hotlist of all the trending songs 
  • Provides access to official videos and live performances 
  • Fully personalized recommendations 

Cons: 

  • The mood-based playlists are not as good

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod (via AirPlay from iPhone)

Install: iOS and Android (free, $9.99/month)

3. Pandora

Should you want your music app to not only let you stream songs but also be a great radio app to let you listen to radio and podcasts (all in one) seamlessly, Pandora could be the right way to go. The best part about this music app is the full-on customization that allows you to create stations depending on artists, genres, and even your favorite songs. Thus, you have a more personalized music listening experience.

Pandora

On the recommendation front, Pandora knows pretty well what sounds cool to your ears and curates songs that seem to be suitable for your taste. In terms of podcasts, it has got a library of hundreds of podcasts from well-known creators. With Pandora Premium ($9.99/monthly), you get unlimited skips and replays.

Besides, it will also let you download music for offline listening as well as create custom playlists. And the Plus version will offer you access to unlimited personalized stations and podcasts as well as let you tune into higher quality audio. Do note that Pandora is not available outside the USA so keep that in mind before deciding on this app.

Pros: 

  • A great app for listening to the radio
  • Option to download music for offline listening
  • Ability to create custom playlists
  • A solid library of podcasts 
  • Personalized music listening experience 

Cons: 

  • Operates only in the United States 

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod

Install: iOS and Android (free, $4.99/month for Pandora Plus)

4. Deezer

If you have a rich taste for audio quality or consider yourself an audiophile, Deezer would be a better bet for you. Packed in with over 55 million songs, it’s second to none when it comes to numbers. Regarding the interface, I find it up to the task (if not at par with the best in the business).

It has a handy shuffle mode which makes it pretty simple to find new tracks. And every time, you come across a song that seems pleasing to your ears, you can add it to your ever-growing collection to quickly access it.

Deezer

Like to keep your tracks perfectly organized? Well, the app offers you many customization options, allowing you to organize your tracks based on artists and genres. Beyond music, you can also discover podcasts, radio stations to catch up with popular programs.

With Deezer Premium ($9.99), you will be able to relish ad-free music and also use Alexa on compatible devices. When it comes to availability, Deezer is available in 182 countries but sadly that vast list doesn’t include India.

Pros: 

  • A huge library of over 56 million songs 
  • Ability to organize music by artist and genre
  • Premium+ version offers top-notch sound quality (320 kBps)
  • Offline mode

Cons: 

  • The UI could be more user-friendly

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod

Install: iOS and Android  (free, $9.99/month)

5. SoundCloud

Here comes the world’s largest music and audio streaming platform by a long-distance! Loaded with over 200 million tracks, SoundCloud will never let your music time go through a low phase. Everything from jazz, hip hop, classical, podcasts to audiobooks that you like to listen to or enjoy tuning into will be there on your radar.

If you always want to keep yourself in sync with the latest offerings from top artists, the app will help you stay in the loop. You can join the huge community of music lovers and also connect with the artists you admire.

SoundCloud

Furthermore, you will have easy access to mixes, chart-topping albums, and live sets. With SoundCloud Go and Go+ ($5.99/$12.99), you will get additional features like offline listening, just 30 seconds of preview, ad-free listening, and more.

Note that while the free version of SoundCloud is available everywhere, its premium versions are available only in a few countries including the US, UK, Canada, Australia, France, Germany, Ireland, Netherlands, and New Zealand. Taking everything into account, it can safely claim to be the best free music app for the iPhone.

Pros: 

  • Mammoth library of over 200 million songs 
  • Ability to connect directly to artists
  • Desired freedom to create playlists for any occasion
  • Curated playlists 

Cons:

  • The UI doesn’t seem intuitive 

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Unsupported (however, it can be played on any smart speaker via Bluetooth, AirPlay, etc)

Install: iOS and Android (free, $5.99/month)

6. Amazon Music

“Amazon Music” has vastly improved in most aspects. And if you are ready to switch your loyalty or simply want to have a music app that can tick off most boxes, this one has to be a pretty safe pick.

The app now has a clean and intuitive interface that makes for easy navigation. As for the music library, Amazon claims to have got a whopping 60 million songs, which are undoubtedly a lot more than you can ever stream. The one apparent advantage of having a big catalog of music is that your search for a unique song will rarely go for a miss. Amazon Music is also pretty smart in recommending songs and stations based on your preference.

Amazon-Music

So, when you want to go for a music drive, you will not have to spend plenty of time to choose the songs that can thrill you. And just in case, you often have to deal with a poor internet connection, you have the liberty to download songs and stream them offline. And with Alexa always there at your beck and call, getting started with music will always be easy for you. Do note that this app is available for free only with Prime membership.

Non-Prime users will need to spend $9.99/month. Amazon Music is available in most countries in some form or the other so you don’t have to worry about its availability. Long story short, you can count on Amazon Music to live up to your demand of being the best free music app for more than one reason.

Pros: 

  • Library of over 60 million songs 
  • Thousands of stations 
  • Ability to stream podcasts 
  • Option to listen to songs in ultra HD
  • Offline listening 

Cons: 

  • Doesn’t score well on the customization front 

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant (via Cast), HomePod (via AirPlay)

Install: iOS and Android (free with Prime, $9.99/month for non-Prime customers)

7. TuneIn Radio

This one is primed for the folks who enjoy listening to the radio. With TuneIn Radio, you have access to over 100,000 radio stations. From news, sports, music to talk radio, you get plenty of options to explore and listen to your favorite content. It offers live commentary to every NFL, MLB, NBA, and NHL games. You can catch up with the trending top shows and famous podcasts on demand.

TuneIn Radio

The app provides access to around 600 music stations, which would be ever ready to entice your music time. Besides, it keeps a tab on your taste and curates music stations that are more geared for different moods. There is also a large library of over 40,000 audiobooks, which would be more than enough to satiate your listening pleasure.

Lastly, only TuneIn Premium (starts at $4.99) can allow you to take advantage of all the features without any restriction. The free version of TuneIn Radio is available in most countries of the world.

Pros: 

  • Ability to stream over 100, 000 radio stations 
  • Provides access to around 600 music stations
  • Live commentary to every NFL, MLB, NBA, and NHL games
  • Also features a great collection of audiobooks 
  • Available in 197 countries

Cons: 

  • Songs/shows customization could be better 

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod

Install: iOS and Android  (free, starts at $4.99/month)

8. iHeartRadio

Though not as feature-packed as some of its noted counterparts, “iHeartRadio” has long been a good platform for music, radio, and podcasts. To ensure your music station delivers only what you wish, you have the option to create personalized radio stations based on your all-time favorite artists.

The music library has loads of tracks of several different genres like Top 40, Country, Rock, Pop, Hip Hop, EDM, R&B, and more. With this app, you can discover a lot of radio stations that are near you or from anywhere in the world. This liberty ensures you can listen to top radio stations, no matter where they exist.

iHeartradio

Whether you would like to tune in to music, news, sports, talk show, or comedy, it would allow you to follow your interest with the needed freedom. As a sports fan, you would be pleased to have popular stations like ESPN Radio and Fox Sports on your radar.

And if you think that all the offerings of iHeartRadio are worth giving a try, you can upgrade to the plus or full version ($5.99/$12.99/monthly). In a nutshell, iHeartRadio is among the most loved free music apps and you should definitely give it a try.

Pros: 

  • Option to listen to thousands of live radio stations 
  • Access to famous sports radio stations like ESPN Radio, Fox Sports Radio, FNTSY Sports Radio, and more 
  • Ability to stream unlimited playlists 
  • Curated playlists 
  • Weekly Mixtape 

Cons: 

  • Songs organization needs improvements 
  • Available in only a few countries including the US, Canada, New Zealand, and Australia

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod/ HomePod mini

Install: iOS and Android (free, $5.99/month)

9. Gaana Music

At first glance, “Gaana Music” may lack the versatility to compete with the likes of Spotify and Apple Music but when you take a close look at its repertoire, you would find it more than good enough.

From classic Bollywood tracks to the chart-topping English songs, it’s got the collection (over 30 million songs) to fit into your different moods. The app is also pretty decent at curating songs in line with the varying demands.

Gaana Music

On the design front, Gaana Music has a fairly good appearance which makes for smooth-sailing navigation. With useful subsections like trending songs, top charts, and featured artists, it’s quite easy to access tracks that are making waves. It also shows the lyrics of the songs so that you can jam along.

Better yet, the voice search makes it more convenient to search and play any song. Not to underestimate, the radio seems to be fully equipped to entertain.

Pros: 

  • A great collection of Bollywood songs 
  • Classic Bollywood tracks
  • Offers access to trending songs 
  • Voice search 
  • Chart-topping English songs

Cons: 

  • Lacks versatility 
  • Available only in India

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod/ HomePod mini (via AirPlay)

Install: iOS and Android (free, Rs. 298/year)

10. JioSaavn

If you are living in India and want a music app that can let you stream millions of songs for free, JioSaavn could be more than a handful. The first thing that caught my attention in this app is the compilation of over 55 million tracks, which are definitely on par with the best in the business.

Speaking of the interface, it appears to be pretty clean and light. The home screen shows you the weekly top 15 songs to keep you in the loop with the biggest movers. Then there is “Trending Today” which allows you quick access to all the songs that are getting a lot of traction.

JioSaavn Music

Not to mention the “Romantic Hot 40” and “EDM Hot 40” that can keep your music time on the charge. If you like tracking the new releases, the app will also offer you instant access to the tracks which have just been rolled out. The editorial picks are thoughtfully-crafted, keeping in mind different tastes.

JioSaavn podcasts aren’t comprehensive, however, it shouldn’t disappoint you. Remember, the free version of JioSaavn can’t provide you access to all the features like high-quality 320kbps, ad-free music, and unlimited skips. So, you will have to get on board with the premium version (around $4/year) to unlock all the features.

Pros: 

  • Curated playlists and radio stations 
  • Weekly top 15 songs
  • Lyrics with live sync 
  • Provides original shows and podcasts 
  • Supports Alexa, AirPlay, Chromecast, and Google Home

Cons:

  • Curated playlists don’t seem up to the mark
  • Not available outside India

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod/ HomePod mini (via AirPlay)

Install: iOS and Android  (free, Rs. 299/year)

11. Wynk Music

For the folks hunting for a reliable platform for streaming Hindi and Punjabi songs, Wynk Music seems to be a good option. While the library of around 2.8 million songs may seem below par as compared to the popular music-streaming apps like Apple Music or JioSaavn, it may prove to be more than enough if you like to listen to top Hindi and Punjabi hits of all time.

Wynk Music

Wynk Music features a decent looking user-interface that’s easier to navigate. Based on the type of songs you like to stream, it provides fully curated playlists to let you quickly access songs that appeal to your taste. Furthermore, you can also create custom playlists for a more personalized music listening experience.

In terms of music quality, Wynk Music is up to the mark. It lets you choose from two music qualities such as 320 and 256 kbps. Notably, you can take advantage of Chromecast to beam music to the supported device.

Pros: 

  • Great platform for streaming Hindi and Punjabi hits 
  • Option to choose from two music qualities such as 320 and 256 kbps
  • Fully curated playlists
  • Create custom playlists

Cons: 

  • The music library is below par in terms of numbers 

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant (via Cast), HomePod (via AirPlay)

Install: iOS and Android  (free, starts at Rs. 29/month)

12. Hungama Music

Another Indian music app that is fully equipped to spice up your music streaming is Hungama Music. Featuring a fairly good library of 10 million songs and music videos, the app can let you listen to both famous Bollywood songs and chart-topping international hits.

Hungama Music

The app also provides live and on-demand channels to let you catch up with your favorite radio programs. And if you like to sing along, you would appreciate the live lyrics. What’s more, the app also works as a useful music player for all of your MP3 songs and lets you keep them perfectly organized.

Just like most of its counterparts, Hungama Music also offers premium tiers with features like offline mode, HD music, and uninterrupted music listening. Overall, it’s got all the bases covered to stake the claim of being one of the finest free music apps for iPhone and Android.

Pros:

  • Great for hindi and regional music
  • Live channels and on-demand content
  • Live lyrics

Cons:

  • Music library is a little lacking

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Google Assistant, HomePod/ HomePod mini (via AirPlay)

Install: iOS and Android  (free, starts at Rs. 99/month)

13. idagio

If you’re a fan of classical music, this is the service for you. Whether you’re looking for Mozart’s piano concerts, Brahm, Mahler, Bach, or any of the classical greats, idagio has you covered. The service offers free access to a huge catalog of classical music albums that you can stream.

idagio free classical music streaming app

Similar to most other music streaming apps, idagio also tailors its suggestions based on the music you like listening to, so you can explore more artists and find new classical music to suit your taste. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of classical music, or you’re just trying to get into the genre, idagio has you covered for hours of listening to the greats perform their best symphonies.

Pros:

  • Great selection of classical music
  • Tailor-made suggestions

Cons:

  • Only has classical music in its catalog
  • You need an account to stream music via idagio

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Not supported (however, you can use Cast, and AirPlay to stream to your Echo, Google Home, and HomePod)

Install: iOS and Android (Free; paid subscriptions at €9.99 per month)

14. LiveXLive

Another great radio app that you can check out for your smartphone is LiveXLive. If you loved using Slacker Radio, rejoice because LiveXLive basically replaces Slacker Radio and you can get most of the same features here. You get access to various radio stations for free, so you can enjoy listening to a range of genres without paying a dime.

livexlive free music streaming app

As the name suggests, LiveXLive places more emphasis on live music instead of on-demand listening that apps like Spotify offer. While the free version should prove enough for most users, you can also subscribe to the service’s premium tier to get access to additional features. If you enjoy radio channels on your phone, LiveXLive is one of the apps you must install.

Pros:

  • Great selection of radio channels, originals, and more
  • Concert and festival live streams

Cons:

  • Only offers credit card billing, can’t be subscribed using Play Store or App Store
  • Free tier limits the number of skips you get

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Alexa, Sonos

Install: iOS and Android (Free; paid tier starts at $3.99 per month)

15. Datpiff

As weird as the name sounds, Datpiff is a music streaming app that does one thing, and does it really well — mixtapes. Yeah, most of use remember the fun it was to create mixtapes of our favourite songs and share them with friends. Well, Datpiff brings the fun of mixtapes into the digital world.

With Datpiff, you get access to a pretty big catalog of mixtapes that you can stream for free. Not only that, the service brings access to underground hip-hop and R&B music as well. You don’t even need to create an account with Datpiff in order to listen to mixtapes for free, and that’s not all, you can even download mixtapes from Datpiff without paying a dime.

Pros:

  • Huge selection of mix-tapes
  • Free to use, no account required
  • Access to underground hip-hop and R&B music

Cons:

  • None, really, except it’s only useful for mixtapes.

Smart Speaker Support:

  • Unsupported (however, you can use Cast and AirPlay to stream to Echo, HomePod, Google Home, and Sonos speakers).

Install: iOS and Android (Free)

Best Offline Music Apps for iPhone and Android

If you are someone who likes to curate their own collection of music then all of the above music apps are not for you. What you need is a good music player app that can help you not only play your offline music but also categorize it, sort it, and keep it accessible. In this section, we are going to mention 5 such offline music player apps that you should check out. What’s more, if you want, you can use Google Cast or AirPlay to play music from these apps on your smart speakers as well, which is pretty cool.

16. Vox Music Player

I’ve always found the “Vox Music Player”  to be a full-fledged music player app. Whether you want to store a lot of music or keep your entire playlists in the right order, it will stand up to your needs.

vox-music-player

Thanks to the support for many audio (including the hi-res) formats such as FLAC, APE, WAV, ALAC, MP3, WMA, OGG, and more, it ensures managing and playing music always remains a convenient task for you.

Better yet, it also lets you stream music from Spotify and SoundCloud. And with over 30’000 radio stations, you will be able to tune into your favorite radio programs as well.

Pros: 

  • Support for many audio formats 
  • Full-fledged music player app
  • Stream music from Spotify and SoundCloud
  • Lyrics with live sync 
  • Original shows and podcasts 

Cons: 

  • UI feels a bit sluggish 

Install: iOS (free, $4.99/month)

17. Radsone Hi-Res Player

For keeping the entire music library perfectly in sync, “Radsone Hi-Res Player” is as good as any music app. With the implementation of Distinctive Clear Technology (DCT), it delivers impressive sound quality by getting rid of digital artifacts.

Radsone Hi-Res Player

Thanks to the sound optimization system, you can also fine-tune the app to get the desired sound. And with the AirPlay support, you will be able to stream your music to the compatible devices. Everything considered; Radsone Hi-Res Player is one of the best offline music player apps for iOS.

Pros: 

  • Delivers impressive sound quality
  • Distinctive Clear Technology
  • Sound optimization system
  • AirPlay support
  • iTunes files sharing

Cons: 

  • UI looks outdated 

Install: iOS (free, in-app purchases available)

Note: We have separately compiled the best offline iPhone music player apps. You should click on the link to check it out.

18. Pulsar Music Player

If versatility is right on top of your priority list, you should try out “Pulsar Music Player”. The modern interface coupled with a wide range of features makes it a full-fledged music player. Features like easy play speed adjustment, convenient tag editing, equalizer, music visualizer, and crossfade can enhance your music listening experience.

Pulsar Music Player

Additionally, it also has the support for Google Voice command and Android Auto. If you have a penchant for customization, you would appreciate various colorful themes that can add plenty of fun elements into the play. Save them for the times where you want to beautify the entire UI.

Pros: 

  • Modern interface
  • Easy play speed adjustment
  • Support for Google Voice command
  • A number of colorful themes 
  • Sleep timer 

Cons: 

  • Home screen widget may drain battery 

Install: Android (free, in-app purchases available)

19. Musicolet

There are very few Android music players in the market that provide as much flexibility as “Musicolet”. It lets you create up to 20 queues, which would be more than enough to keep your tracks perfectly in line.

Musicolet

One notable feature of this app is that it allows you to manage queues while catching up with another queue. Sporting a pretty minimalistic design, it makes navigating your music library quite straightforward. With the handy tag editor, you will be able to edit tags and album arts of many songs at one go.

Pros: 

  • Super handy tag editor
  • A pretty minimalistic design
  • Create up to 20 queues
  • Supports multiple queues 
  • Folder browsing 

Cons: 

  • The home screen widget doesn’t work smoothly 

Install: Android (free, in-app purchases available)

20. Canaree

To take complete control of tons of songs and keep them in the apple-pie-order, “Canaree” is always one of the better picks. Featuring a nifty UI and smooth player controls, the app doesn’t take much time to carve out a niche. The floating windows make it more convenient for tracking videos.

Canaree

And with the offline lyrics support, it gives your jamming a bit more leeway. Speaking of the built-in metadata tag editor, it is sufficient to handle your tracks, albums, and artists. Moreover, the support for Android Auto, Android Wear, and Google voice commands put Canaree in the elite league of the best offline music player apps for Android. 

Pros: 

  • Better player controls 
  • Offline lyrics support
  • Floating windows
  • Built-in metadata tag editor
  • Support for Android Auto

Cons: 

  • Music organization needs enhancements 

Install: Android (free, in-app purchases available)

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I get free music on my iPhone?

There are several music apps like Spotify and YouTube Music that you can use to get free music on your iPhone.

What is the best app to get free music?

Going by the numbers, Spotify is by the far the best app to get free music. Though YouTube Music and Deezer are no less impressive.

How do I put music on my iPhone 2021?

You can use Finder/iTunes to transfer locally stored music from your computer to the iPhone or iPad seamlessly.

How can I put music on my iPhone without using iTunes?

There are several highly-efficient iTunes alternatives such as DearMob and WinX MediaTrans that can let you transfer music from your computer to your iPhone and iPad with ease.

Is Apple Music free?

Though Apple Music is not available for free, you can get a free trial of 3 months. During festive times, Apple also offers a free trial of up to 6 months.

What is Hi-Fi Audio?

Hi-Fi audio is basically high fidelity audio. It’s a term used to signify music that’s streaming at a higher quality, usually lossless, or audiophile grade streaming. A couple of apps offer Hi-Fi audio streaming, but none of them are free. You can get lossless streaming in Apple Music, Tidal, etc.

Time to Get the Most Out of Your Favorite Music App

That ends our article on the best free music apps that you can get for your iPhone and Android. In this article, we have assembled the list of best free music streaming apps and offline music player apps for you.

Do check them out and let us know which is your favorite among them all. Also, if we missed out on any app, drop its name down in the comments section.

#Tags
comment Comments 4
  • William says:

    I kinda like it

  • Rajesh Mishra says:

    Thanks for the great compliment!

  • Rahul says:

    try retro music for android

  • Adi A says:

    I felt “Retro Music Player” to be the best Offline Music Player app on Android due to it’s Clean UI and Tons of customization

Leave a Reply