The Witcher Season 4 Early Reviews Are Out, and the Reception Is Mixed

The Witcher Season 4 is finally here with all the episodes on Netflix. The fourth season has been on the lens for one specific reason, and we all know it. Liam Hemsworth takes on the mantle to play Geralt in the new season, and fans just can’t seem to expect it. And now that the fourth season is out, fans have a better idea of whether the creators finally did justice to the story and if Liam actually looks good as the Butcher of Blaviken. However, if you are wondering if you should go for Season 4 despite the cast change, it’s better that you read some early reviews of the season.

Some Early Reviews for The Witcher Season 4 Paint a Bad Picture

Of course, despite all the negativity surrounding Season 4, fans were hoping that the show would rise from the ashes. However, if we look at the early reviews for The Witcher Season 4, it seems like the latest season has majorly disappointed the hardcore fans of the incredible franchise.

Chase Hutchinson from The Wrap, for instance, makes it clear in his review that Liam Hemsworth doesn’t bring enough range or spark as Henry Cavill. Chase also says that every other actor does a pretty good job in the latest season, and of course, the gruesome ending and the action sequences might pull back some fans. However, that doesn’t change the fact that there’s a void after Cavill’s departure that Lima fails to fill.

Hemsworth’s Geralt can wield all the magic and drink all the potions in the world, it still won’t help this character come back to life.

Then, there’s Sarah Dempster from The Guardian, who seems to agree on the fact that Liam, no matter how charismatic he is in real life, fails to match the brilliance of Henry Cavill as Geralt. Sarah says that Liam’s accent for Geralt is as uneven as the overall narrative of The Witcher Season 4.

The replacement that Netflix has chosen for lead actor Henry Cavill is utterly lacking in his predecessor’s likability. The ex-Neighbours actor is a scowling lunk who brings a wildly uneven vibe to this fantasy drama.

Sure, these negative reviews may disappoint several fans of The Witcher, but hey, it’s not all negative. There are, in fact, some reviews that give you hope.

But Some Early Reviews Suggest That You Should Give The Witcher Season 4 a Chance

Of course, the negativity around Liam’s portrayal of Geralt can’t be ignored. However, there are some reviews that paint a rather good picture for Season 4 of The Witcher.

Aramide Tinubu from Variety, for instance, says in her review that The Witcher Season 4 is an upgrade. Aramide has praised the fact that the latest season of The Witcher on Netflix zeroes in on Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri. She also says the action sequences and the straightforward narrative are major strengths of the fourth season.

Most fans of the show have likely been bracing themselves to see how Hemsworth takes on a character Cavill has long mastered. Although the voice isn’t quite the same, as the episodes move forward and given the season’s straightforward structure, which zeros in on Geralt, Yennefer and Ciri separately, the transition is mostly seamless.

That’s not it, as Jamie Parker from Comicbook also praises The Witcher Season 4 while also making it clear that it’s not perfect. Jamie says in his review that in the fourth season, Liam delivers a Strong Turn as Geralt of Rivia. He also praises the character arc of Yennefer, but says that Ciri feels like she’s left behind in the show. However, other than the fact that Liam seems great as Geralt, Jamie likes the latest season majorly because of all the amazing new characters.

The Witcher Season 4 isn’t perfect, plagued with pacing issues and some forgettable characters, but the season is still a lot of fun for fantasy fans. Hemsworth fits in easily with the world of The Witcher, proving to viewers that the show is better than ever and can still be Netflix’s flagship fantasy series.

There are, of course, several other early reviews for The Witcher Season 4; however, this right about sums it all up. It’s a mixed bag. While some people like what the latest season has to offer, there are some fans who can’t seem to accept Liam as the new Geralt.