- The Arcane Pickaxe in The Forge is the superior and more cost-effective choice, featuring better luck (+50%), a mining speed bonus, and three rune slots for a price of $125,000.
- Magma Pickaxe is a niche purchase at $150,000, offering higher base power (135) for tougher rocks but with fewer rune slots (2) and a modest luck boost (+46%).
- To acquire the Arcane Pickaxe, players must complete the quest to return Bard's Guitar, which yields the Unknown Key needed to unlock the Fallen Angel's Cave.
If you have spent enough time in The Forge, you have probably hit the same wall as everyone else. Choosing between the Magma and Arcane pickaxe can feel like gambling with your wallet, so it helps to know what separates them before you pour your savings into the wrong one. This guide breaks down the Magma vs Arcane pickaxe in The Forge in a simple way so you can pick the tool that actually pushes your run forward.
The Forge Magma vs Arcane Pickaxe Stats
If you go through our pickaxe progression guide, then you will know which one is a better pick and why. But it is important to decide between Magma vs Arcane, as both are among the most valuable pickaxes in The Forge. Before we dive deep, here are the Magma and Arcane pickaxe stats in The Forge:
Stats Magma Arcane Mine Power 135 115 Mining Speed None +10% Luck Boost +46% +50% Rune Slot 2 3 Price $150,000 $125,000
Magma Pickaxe
The Magma pickaxe is good in the late mid-game and works well when you need to break tougher rocks. It delivers strong mining power and shows up right before you reach the volcanic depths. The price is the catch. At $150,000, it feels steep for a tool that offers only two rune slots and a modest 46 percent luck boost. Unless The Forge adds a rock that demands more than 115 base damage to break, the Magma pickaxe stands as a niche buy rather than a must-have upgrade.
Arcane Pickaxe
The Arcane pickaxe sits behind a locked zone, so you need to return Bard’s Guitar to earn the Unknown Key. Use that key to open the Fallen Angel’s Cave, and you can buy the pickaxe for $125,000. Even though it costs less than Magma, it delivers better mining speed, far better luck, and room for three runes. It works as the ideal pickaxe to carry you toward the Demonic pickaxe or whatever new tool arrives next.
The Forge Magma vs Arcane Pickaxe: Which One to Get?
The Arcane Pickaxe is generally the superior choice, despite requiring a quest to unlock, because it offers better mining speed, significantly higher luck, and three rune slots for a lower price of $125,000. This pickaxe easily gets you all the important ores in The Forge. So, whether you want to make money fast or get the best weapons and armors in The Forge, this is the best pickaxe right now.
In contrast, the Magma Pickaxe costs more at $150,000, provides only a modest 46% luck boost, and has just two rune slots. While the Magma Pickaxe offers strong mining power for tougher rocks, its high price and limited features make it a niche purchase. Therefore, the Arcane Pickaxe is the ideal and more cost-effective tool to acquire, serving as an excellent bridge to the next tier of pickaxes, like the Demonic pickaxe.
So, which pickaxe are you getting in the battle of Magma vs Arcane in The Forge? Let us know in the comments.
The Arcane Pickaxe is highly recommended for general progression. It is cheaper at $125,000, provides a +10% Mining Speed boost, offers better luck (+50%), and features three rune slots.
The next major upgrade after the Arcane Pickaxe is the Demonic Pickaxe. It is a top-tier tool, costing $500,000, and comes with very high Mine Power (175) and three rune slots.
